CommunityPanel

Community Panel

 A group drawn from the impacted community, which acts as a durable sounding board, guide, and source of feedback you can go back to for feedback throughout the project.

 

IMG_2596-2×1

Outcomes

 A durable source of feedback from community sources gathered across a long time period.

Preparation

  1. Identify how large of a community panel you can adequately sustain across the project time period. We suggest at least eight (8) people minimum as not everyone will be able to make every session, and suggest no more than 20 people total because after that it becomes logistically difficult to coordinate schedules.
  2. Decide if you will ask participants to meet in-person, remotely, or hybrid. We suggest a hybrid approach which allows group cohesion to form, but give people ways to participate which matches their lives, health needs, and schedule.
  3. Define what types of people you wish to recruit: we suggest a broad cross section of people the project or proposal will affect. Go broad, and make sure you use this opportunity to connect with a wide range of people across the socioeconomic spectrum.
  4. Create a longlist based on asking the community, subject matter experts, local electeds, government workforce, and civil society. Edit this long list to a short list and send out invitations, preferably as customized as possible.
  5. Decide on how you will compensate participants: you are asking them to sign up for at least a few hours, if not longer. Refer to minimum wage as a guide.

Metrics

  • Participation rate: total per session, percentage of group, and trends
  • Feedback: number of submissions, quality of submissions (subjective)
  • Implementation: track how feedback links to project change
  • Alignment/deviation from Community Profile
  • Percentage (and categorical breakdown) of participants who are from underserved communities

Accessibility

  • All physical spaces shall be fully accessible according to the Americans with Disabilities Act, remote software shall also strive to follow accessibility guidelines.
  • Offer accommodations throughout the process. Check in with participants prior to sessions, and at the beginning of the session to see if they need anything or if there’s anything you should know before you get started. 
  • Review Language Access Plan and Limited English Proficiency (LEP) requirements to provide multilingual content.

Equity & Inclusion

  •  How are you balancing panel participation to reflect the Community Profile and EO 13985?
  • Where possible find balance by choosing panel members who represent underserved communities per EO13985 Sec. 8 (see Engagement Plan & Guide)

PRA Considerations

  • PRA approval is not required when asking if members of the public are interested in participating
  • Agencies should compensate participants for their time and expertise when conducting user research
  • PRA approval is not needed when an agency is collecting information from nine or fewer members of the public within a 12-month period

For more infomation:

DSCF2646-square

Activation

  1. Schedule an in-person kickoff workshop, outlining the overall commitment, the code of conduct you will create, the expectations of the panel, and project details.
  2. Use additional tactics such as Community Voting, Voicemail, Postcards, and Workshop to make feedback inclusive.
  3. Conduct the following panel sessions as a mix of in-person and remote sessions, varying the day of the week and time to allow flexibility. Not everyone can do a breakfast or after work session. See Engagement Spectrum for guidance on inclusive scheduling.

After the event

  1. Send all participants the meeting minutes and session summaries, along with a reminder for following sessions.
  2. Ask for feedback on how to make the session better.
Staffing needs
  • Part-time panel coordination & scheduling logistics

  • 2-3 people during session

  • Compensation (optional)

Setup needs
  • A room large enough to hold the panel or remote software
Suggested duration
  • 1–2 hours per session
Core behaviors segments
  • Sleeping
  • Scrambling
Useful to:
players-CoS-thin

Build momentum and evidence for Executive.

players-topic-heads-thin

Validate course of action and gather evidence.

players-practitioners

To understand the problem space in order to act.

Journey moments:
What propels the Players to decide on a course of action?
How are the Players prompted to Act?

EXAMPLES IN THE WORLD

Camper_IDEO_GA0028-square

Reimagining the Civic Commons

Helping 8 city teams prototype at the urban scale to heal trauma

Tactical Democracy is a toolkit to help you make meaningful person–to–person engagement in order to empower successful communities.

Learn about the Mindsets you need, how the Players behave and act; what Situations might be best to
deploy Tactics for engagement, to move the Players through their Journey, creating deeper empowerment.

Whoa, there's a lot of terms – check out the Glossary of Terms, and if you want to see everything, goto the sitemap.

Read some blog posts: